Nothing To Hide
At 3:45pm yesterday, I boarded my Amtrak train home. The conductor assigned us seats based on where we were going. He told me seat 5, but I picked 6, since it was in the same spot, but a window seat. Ordinarily I dread some weirdo sitting down next to me on long trips like this. But I started feeling optimistic when a dude in a motorcycle shirt sat down next to me and started cursing about how long of a walk down to the train it was.
And within five minutes, I somehow had this guy’s entire life story. I could tell you right now the last three jobs he’s had, and where he’s lived and worked for at least the last thirty years, and a history of health problems. I know he’s got at least two kids, where his siblings live, and that his mother is 89 years old and lives near him in Florida. He showed me photos of his front yard, which the neighborhood association was always on his ass about because he kept it as a “jungle.” Last year he picked 61 pineapples in his yard, which is no bigger than a regular suburban lot. He told me about how he caught his last girlfriend on the phone making plans to fuck some other dude while he himself was in the house right there asleep, and then kicked her out - for the seventh time, he said. But this one was for good.
It’s just funny how open some people are. And not just funny, but great. I know if he’d caught me in a different mood, I might not have been so receptive. I might have strained to put my headphones off and vanish back into my thoughts. But somehow I did not. Somehow I listened eagerly to stories about his days as a pot-smoking engineer on freight trains, and the two times that his train hit cars on the tracks. He asked me if I’d ever “smoked grass” and I responded emphatically yes. Then he told me about how his son had “white powder” and a “fat one” waiting for him at the end of the line in Toledo.
One other awesome thing he showed me: he used to work in a factory which made jet engine components for the military. They’d made a particular engine for one of the stealth planes, only for the government guys to say it wasn’t powerful enough and scrapped the whole thing. Somehow, this guy had managed to procure one of the old engine housings, and had turned it into a composter for his garden. He showed me the picture.
Ordinarily, I go around like your typical conspiracy theorist, seeing the shrinking of personal privacy and liberty. The Surveillance State seems to loom large on the horizon to me. They made us show ID’s on the train, for chrissakes! But none of that would matter to a guy like the one who sat down next to me. He was just eager to share his life with any and everyone equally. All you had to do was be receptive and maybe share something back. Hell, I heard him tell at least two other people the story about how many pineapples he picked last year…
One time, a couple years ago, I was discussing with a coworker how Baltimore City was installing a whole bunch of cameras in public places - ostensibly to cut down on crime. He said something to me which I’ve heard parroted elsewhere endlessly, “Why should I worry about all that, if I’m not doing anything wrong?” I’m sure most “regular” people think this. They’re out there, playing the game, and and they work hard to (mostly) follow the rules. So why should they worry about referrees and penalty boxes?
I guess at one point I was more interested in “convincing” people that they should care. That the rules were going to be changed on them, and the borders of the playing field would be redrawn if we weren’t paying attention. But meeting my friend on the train has given me a new perspective on the whole thing.
I once came up with the idea that fame is nothing more than having people think about you while you’re not around. And I think this is somehow applicable to the fantasy of surveillance and tracking. It’s nothing more or less than the idea that somebody somewhere gives a shit. That your actions aren’t in vain. That they aren’t just vanishing into the ether. That they are being recorded, shared and analyzed. “Huh, why did he do that? Oooh, what a dangerous little scamp she must be? Did you see the books they bought at the store? We’ve gotta keep track of these two!”
It’s sort of like that Andy Warhol quote about everyone in the future being famous for fifteen minutes. The Surveillance State will give us a chance to feel famous - or at the very least infamous. If you want to see how the Surveillance Wars will be fought, just look at Hollywood celebrities and their eternal war with the paparazzi.
I’ve wondered before why on earth a government would want to put all of its citizens under constant surveillance. Where’s the money in stamping out freedom of expression? It seems stupid. In all likelihood, I think we’ll find out that it actually is not that at all. That hardened conspiracy theorists need to remember to “follow the money”. I think at the other end of it we won’t find windowless secret jail cells (well, some of us might…), but products and advertisements tailored perfectly to our personal profiles.
In any event, I think we’re left with the question: well, what do we do? Do we just give in? Do we just adopt the asinine notion of “If we’re not doing anything wrong, we have nothing to fear?” I don’t see the use in that. But I’m beginning to understand that none of us really have anything to fear. What do any of us have to hide anyway? The very weird idiosyncracies and inane details of our lives are the very things which make us who we are. We can sit like a dragon in a cave hoarding them, or we can share ourselves and our experiences with people. Sure it might make a stranger feel weird if you start telling them about your drug habits or your garden or your cheating girlfriend. If we spent more time telling each other our life stories, maybe we’d feel less need to be inundated with the ridiculous tales they try to tell us on TV. We’d see right through them as fake and hollow, because they were missing the weird, gritty, and sometimes embarrassing details of real life. It’s time to take off the headphones and actually talk to the person sitting next to you. At the end of the day, it’s real and it’s honest and it’s human. In a nutshell, it’s us.

![[tmbchr]™](/journal/popocculture-blog-logo.jpg)
May 19th, 2005 at 7:42 pm
I see what you’re getting at here. Thoughts like “why do i care if they watch me, im not doing anything wrong?” have always got me aswell. I also got annoyed when people said this, although I couldnt explain to them why.
And now I feel annoyed because I can’t write something which counters that quote…
But “The very weird idiosyncracies and inane details of our lives are the very things which make us who we are.” This is true, but those weird bits are not meant to be experienced by spooks on the other end of cam right? It’s not… natural?
Hmph.
May 19th, 2005 at 8:51 pm
i know what you’re saying. i dont feel like ive totally refuted that argument, but i’ve taken a step in doing so.
your comment about spooks watching us through a camera has also got me thinking… what if we could somehow “inspire” the government creeps who would be monitoring our lives? what if we for them became celebrity demi-gods who acted out for them the fantasies that they were too repressed or psychologically underdeveloped to enact themselves?
it would almost be like we were their dreams, and somehow we were trying to spiritually redeem them through our actions.
May 19th, 2005 at 10:36 pm
..Which reminds me of the fab graffitti seen on a wall at an antiglobalisation blockade:
‘Your spectacle is my adventure’.
May 19th, 2005 at 10:40 pm
The problem with the “I’m not doing anything wrong” mentality is that they will be, because the more control is gotten, the more is desired- and the more wil become “wrong.”
May 20th, 2005 at 12:55 am
yeah thats what i was trying to say about the rules and borders being redrawn. if youre always making sure that youre “inside the box” you won’t even notice as the box becomes smaller and smaller.
May 20th, 2005 at 7:37 am
That idea of us becoming demi-gods to our surveyors is awesome! We could start a revolution from the inside. Our actions and our “being” would rekindle that spark that lies in all the guys watching us, like you said, that repressed spirituality or mentality…
I think i’ll post on this because I need to sort it out in my head, it’s running around disrupting things in my mind ha.
May 20th, 2005 at 2:54 pm
[…]
May 20, 2005 The camera, the car and the fear
Tim recently posted something about some guy he was sat next to on a train on his journ […]
May 20th, 2005 at 4:14 pm
[…] from dandelions to evil ultradimensional entities all in one day. Viva verisimillitude! Tim and Dan both have exceptional posts about the encroaching surveillance state, b […]
May 20th, 2005 at 6:09 pm
This all reminds me of what Grant Morrison had to say at the Disinfo convention in 2000 (you can find the clip on emule or on a dvd).He said something about the vast amount of street surveillance cameras being set up in the UK, and that if ‘they’ are watching us anyway,we (the mutants) should take the opportunity to show the powers-that-be what we are really like and that we are not afraid.We needed to shove our uniqueness back in their faces and show them just how weird & wonderful we are and how we shall inevitably overcome by being fearless. Something like that,anyway.
May 20th, 2005 at 8:12 pm
kill fear!
May 21st, 2005 at 3:51 am
Like Kinsey examining the sex lives of everyday people and finding out what freaks people really were, even “back in the day” before “those people” were conducting their business in front of God and everybody.
God played a really mean trick on some poor, poor monkeys a long time ago.
May 21st, 2005 at 7:33 am
Uhm, Kinsey did not examine the sex lives of “ordinary” people. He mainly interviewed prostitutes and similar people. His whole research was seriously flawed.
May 21st, 2005 at 7:35 am
Check out the book “Libido Dominandi: Sexual Liberation as Political Control”. The author is kind of weird, but it’s a goldmine of information, tho you don’t necessarly agree wit his conclusions.
May 25th, 2007 at 11:11 am
[…] Tim and Dan both have exceptional posts about the encroaching surveillance state, both coming to the excellent conclusion that the best way to approach the monitors of the Authorities (be they temporal or Archonic) is without fear. Here’s a great excerpt from Dan’s post that illustrates the point: So in light of that view it seems that police-state style surveillance merely re-ignites issues that are inherent in our human makeup and always have been. Those at different psychological stages are the ones who are disagreeing. But I still don’t think this justifies the surveillance. There’s one more issue, which I think explains why our rulers want this surveillance and why we must “neutralise” it. […]