The latest from Daniel Pinchbeck:
These days I feel lost in the immense suffering and madness of our world. Something has snapped in the spirit of the time; events have gone beyond human capacity to control, predict or even conceptualize. Those who insist they know what is happening are merely pretending, or dissembling. When novelty arises, when old structures disintegrate before new patterns reveal themselves, there are no experts.
When I went to see Daniel Pinchbeck speak recently at Barnes & Noble in Seattle, the first thing he said to the audience was that he “feels like a robot” having delivered the “same spiel” so many times up until then. This article, or at least this paragraph, to me seems to indicate that maybe he is beginning to find a new spiel, or else, maybe his old one has finally collapsed.
I don’t know the man personally, and my past antagonism towards him publicly certainly isn’t likely to me to win his friendship any time soon. Nor is this current probe into the dark recesses of his mind which he is kind enough to throw a window into through his writing. But I have to wonder aloud, if only for my own sake (because I have been there, God knows), whether he’s perceiving the state of the world accurately, or if the meltdown he’s feeling has its roots in his own life.
My speculation, of course, ends there, as only he knows what’s in his heart. I know that within the tangled and overgrown recesses of my own heart though, that the times when I myself am going through the worst of it are the times when the world around me seems most tortured, most out of control and most ready to burst. Those times, fortunately, have always turned themselves around in the end when I most needed them to. And the world itself, somehow, has remained afloat regardless of my bobbings up and down.
I was once a great deal more in tune with Pinchbeck’s overall message: back when it had to do with taking positive action in the world, and looking for real solutions, rather than becoming possessed with Apocalyptic fervor. Reading the above, I wonder what happened to that Daniel Pinchbeck, what trials and lessons the man behind the words endured which so heartily knocked him off that course. May it be that they are healed in their own time in whatever way is most appropriate. For I can tell you, from my own experience (which strengthens every day as beautiful people and amazing opportunities unfold around me), that we were not sent here to suffer.
Those who live now in Hell and confusion within this life have the ability to live hereafter in Heaven. And they do not have to wait another five years for “paradigms to shift” or for the “overt irrationality revealed by the current financial crisis might [to] act as a necessary awakening, leading to a large-scale shift in values.”
It’s not that our values need to change, so much as it is that we need to stand true to them at all costs, and actualize them in everything we do into this world.
We have to master first ourselves, take control and responsibility for who we are, and work continuously to improve one another’s experience of life. This, to me, is the only “foolproof” plan for a troubled time: to recognize that it is not the time or the world that is troubled, but it is us as individuals. The world has no experience of itself except through us, its walking antennas. If each of us can fix that which Epictetus would say is within the sphere of our moral purpose, we will come to a place of rest and peace, and we can literally do anything, including not suffering any more. The choice, as always, lies squarely in your hands.
- END -
ASSOCIATED CONTENT @TMBCHR (Auto-Generated)

15 Comments
I agree. This has more to do with an internal state than an external one but they are linked. I’m sure the people living through the aftermath of WW I, the Depression, during the Holocaust etc. felt the same way. This man shows how high the human spirit can grow despite hideous, world changing circumstances. I’m sure there are lots more like him who never become public figures.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viktor_Frankl
Shoot, I forgot that I salvaged Frankl’s book from my old house. Need to get reading that!
Reading this again, it strikes me how absurdly defeatist this is to say. We always have the ability to make choices and to improve our experience. There is nothing that exists or can exist that lies apart from our God-given ability to Reason and to Act.
I find myself worrying less about peak oil. It struck me today when I saw a commercial about alternative fuels. I said to myself “People more qualified then me are working on this.”
Sphere of the moral purpose, baby!
Hi Tim,
I feel that you manage to twist my ideas and intentions in everything you write about my work. It is unfortunate.
Of course, I still believe in “positive action” in the world. That is why we started Reality Sandwich - http://realitysandwich.com - a media website that will develop into a social network for sharing tools and exchanging resources as well as information. In fact, I see the naked revealing of the current financial system as a positive thing. We may need to see a collapse of “fictitious capital” before we can readjust to dealing with the natural capital of the planet.
In the last decades, the economic system has acted as a funnel siphoning wealth and resources upward from the many to the few. The inequities have grown to become monstrous disproportions, creating an oligarchy that is now building its own private armies.
However there is huge potential for transformation right now - I recommend Michael Hardt and Antonio Negri’s book “Multitude” as one cogent analysis.
yours,
dp
Thanks for your comments Daniel! I’m happy to have you around to discuss things, as I think you are an extremely intelligent person. However, as you know, I often disagree with your views! I in fact value your viewpoint the more as it is not always in accord with mine and challenges me to look at my own attitudes in new ways.
I recognize my own failings in our communications quite readily, but have you considered that perhaps you are simply not communicating as effectively as you could?
In what way will Reality Sandwich transform into that? Last I heard of it, you were just posting attacks by John Lash to other websites.
You see this as only a recent development?
So you’re going to combat massive armies of the oligarchy with a website?
You write, “We *may* need to see a collapse” and I maintain that it is your choice to see a collapse as necessary. You are actively selecting towards a particular reality - one which is almost certainly not positive in that it “requires” collapse. And this is not me twisting your words.
No, this is not the time for reading more books and for engaging in further “cogent analysis.” This is the time for people to master themselves, perfecting their own experience of life, and improving that of all others.
And we do not need to wait for 2012 to happen. And we do not require a collapse to change. These are at best wrong, and at worst dangerous attitudes to hold.
yeah, forget collapse. I was thinking about that in regards to “The Secret” A certian segment of the population, myself formerly included, is attracting this narrative, idea, or whatever, of a collapse of civilization.
What a Downer. Seriously. I am thinking maybe if it stays kind of fringe, it will just attract shitty things into the lives of those people focusing on this dream of “collapse.” But if it really catches on, I am sure it would have enough collective energy to really happen.
“Transformation” I think is a much better word picture. “Revolution” has become trite perhaps.
There are different kinds of revolutions, though, some are peaceful and not bloody at all.
But anyway, this collapse thing is so passive aggressive and negative. Basically its all about hating powerful people and wishing bad things to happen to them. Its not empowering.
Yeah, fuck the collapse. Fuck 2012. This is the Super Century. It’s gonna be better than all the rest combined!
I was gonna say, Fuck! But I toned it down to forget so my point wouldn’t be lost.
Yeah, Supercentury! You know if you read RAW, he would have liked that idea better then all this collapse shit a lot of his fans seem to be into for some reason.
The collapse in any form is what RAW and Leary would have called a loser script. Write a winner script. Then live it. That’s the point of life. We’re not here to suffer.
Right, that part too. But I was thinking along the lines of this huge global transformation he was envisioning in “Prometheus Rising”
I get the point and I don’t follow Mr. Pinchbeck’s work so I don’t know his context but “fictitious capital” is what many of the six billion people on Earth base their lives on. Collapse and creative destruction are great concept but it’s funny that none of the advocates for these things are creative enough to come up with safety nets.
This morning I read an article about the introduction of genetically modified seed stocks in India by Monsanto, ADM etc. Many failed and an estimated 28,000 farmers committed suicide in the decade to follow. Their collapse has already happened, now what?
http://www.democracynow.org/article.pl?sid=06/12/13/1451229
No, they are not great concepts. They are hysterical antics.
Curious, this post-collapse meme fizzing away at the cutting edge of whatever this sub-blogospherelet is. I started working on critical revision of various collapsist and peak-oil beliefs I had picked up a month ago or so. Part of the reason I’ve started lurking at this site again: I saw Tim’s response to some Christian telling him he’s going to hell and it was so… nice! Compassionate, empathic, grounded. Suddenly realised I was reading far too much negativity into my life at other sites.
But I do have to ask, since we’re all no longer waiting for 2012, maybe it’s time to change the “by Tim Boucher, 2012, Creative Commons” bit at the bottom? How about 2112? That would give us all some breathing space…
Yeah, I added that in as a joke to see if anybody would notice it
One Trackback
[...] Lost In The Immense Suffering [...]